Michigan State vs Notre Dame Hockey Review: Spartans Fall 3-2 in Overtime in Big Ten Opener

Notre Dame 3, Michigan State 2 final score graphic from Michigan Sports Entertainment

Michigan State led twice on Thursday night. The Spartans never trailed in regulation. Still, they left South Bend with a loss. Notre Dame answered both Michigan State leads, forced overtime, and won 3-2 just 21 seconds into the extra period at Compton Family Ice Arena. As a result, No. 4 Michigan State opened Big Ten play with an overtime loss and fell to 6-3-0 on the season.

Shane Vansaghi scored both Michigan State goals. He gave the Spartans a 1-0 lead early in the second period. Later, he restored the lead at 2-1 in the third period. However, Notre Dame responded quickly each time. Sammy Nelson tied the game in the second period. Then Pano Fimis tied it again in the third. Finally, Nelson scored his second goal of the night in overtime to end it.

The loss snapped a long run of success in this series. Michigan State had won 10 straight games against Notre Dame, a streak that dated back to the 2023-24 season. Notre Dame improved to 5-6-0 with its third straight win. Meanwhile, Michigan State earned one point for the overtime loss and sits at 0-0-0-1 in Big Ten play.

A Scoreless First Period, With One Close Call

Notre Dame started the game on the front foot. The Fighting Irish outshot Michigan State 10-6 in the first period. They controlled much of the opening 20 minutes. Even so, neither team scored, and the game went to the first intermission tied 0-0.

Michigan State thought it had the first goal. Vansaghi tipped a shot from defenseman Chase Reid at the point. However, officials reviewed the play and waved the goal off. The tip came on a high stick, so the score stayed 0-0.

The Spartans also had the game’s first power play in the period. Henry Nelson took a slashing penalty for Notre Dame. Michigan State could not convert, though. That missed chance set the tone for a night when every goal was hard to earn.

The Second Period: Vansaghi Scores, Nelson Answers

The game opened up early in the second period. Vansaghi got his goal back at 1:56 of the period. He picked up a puck from Eric Nilson and drove hard to the net. Then he flipped the puck over Notre Dame goaltender Patrick Quinlan for a 1-0 lead.

Notre Dame answered almost right away. Just over three minutes into the period, Danny Nelson threaded a pass to his younger brother Sammy on the back side. Sammy redirected the puck into the net, and the game was tied 1-1.

After that, the goaltenders took over. Quinlan made several quality saves in the final 10 minutes of the second period. He kept the game tied heading into the second intermission. Michigan State freshman Joshua Ravensbergen matched him at the other end. As a result, a period that started with two quick goals ended with none in the final 16 minutes.

Shop Michigan State gear at The MSE Shop

The Third Period: Another Lead, Another Quick Answer

Notre Dame pushed hard early in the third period. The Fighting Irish outshot Michigan State 11-4 over the first 10 minutes of the period. Yet Michigan State scored first anyway. Vansaghi struck again with 12:17 left in regulation, scoring off a pass from Nilson. His second goal of the night put the Spartans in front 2-1.

Once again, the lead did not last long. Fimis tied the game 2-2 at 10:59 of the third period. Henry Nelson fired a shot on goal, and Ravensbergen made the first save. However, Fimis collected the loose puck near the crease and placed his shot past the Michigan State goaltender.

The final nine minutes brought a Michigan State push. The Spartans attempted 16 shots in that closing stretch. Nine of them reached the net. Quinlan turned away every one. He finished the third period with 12 saves. Consequently, neither team found a winner in regulation, and the game went to overtime tied 2-2.

Overtime: Over in 21 Seconds

Overtime lasted less than half a minute. Paul Fischer won the opening faceoff for Notre Dame and moved the puck into the Michigan State end. His shot was stopped, but the rebound came free. Danny Nelson battled to keep possession against two Spartans. Michigan State never touched the puck in the extra period.

Then Sammy Nelson collected it. He skated around the slot, turned, and fired a shot past Ravensbergen on the blocker side. The goal came 21 seconds into overtime. It gave Sammy Nelson the first multi-goal game of his college career. It also gave Notre Dame its first win over Michigan State in 11 meetings.

Top Performers for Michigan State

Vansaghi was clearly Michigan State’s best player. He scored both Spartan goals. He also had the disallowed goal in the first period. On another night, that line could have been a hat trick and a road win. Instead, it became a strong individual performance in a team loss.

Nilson played a supporting role on both goals. He had a hand in Vansaghi’s first goal. Then he set up the second goal with a pass in the third period. That production matters for Michigan State. The Spartans need secondary scoring behind their top names, and Nilson provided it on the road.

Ravensbergen’s night was harder to judge. He kept the game scoreless through the first period while Notre Dame pressed. He also made the initial save on the play that became the tying goal in the third period. However, he allowed three goals, including the overtime winner. Even so, his defense gave up clean looks on all three Notre Dame goals.

Top Performers for Notre Dame

Sammy Nelson decided the game. He tied it in the second period. Then he won it in overtime. Both of his goals came with an assist from one of his older brothers. Danny Nelson assisted on the tying goal. He also finished the night with two assists and a team-high 12 points on the season.

Fimis scored the other Notre Dame goal. It was his second straight game with a goal and his fourth straight game with a point. He also went 10-for-15 at the faceoff dot, which led the Fighting Irish. Those faceoff wins helped Notre Dame control key moments, including the start of overtime.

Quinlan, however, may have been Notre Dame’s most important player. The freshman made 33 saves and allowed only two goals. He earned his third win in as many games. Most importantly, he stopped all nine shots he faced in the final nine minutes of regulation, when Michigan State pushed hardest for a winner.

Shop Detroit Lions, Tigers, Pistons and Red Wings gear at The MSE Shop

The Numbers Behind the Result

Blocked shots told a clear story. Notre Dame blocked 17 shots, while Michigan State blocked only five. That gap shrank the Spartans’ shooting lanes all night. It also helps explain why Michigan State’s late push produced pressure but no goal.

Notre Dame also tied the game quickly both times. The Fighting Irish answered the first Michigan State goal within about a minute of game time. They answered the second goal in just over three minutes. In other words, Michigan State never got to play with a lead for long. A young road team needs time to settle after scoring. The Spartans never received it.

Discipline and special teams stayed in the background. The only penalty noted in the recaps was the first-period slashing call on Henry Nelson. Michigan State did not score on that power play. After that, the game was decided entirely at even strength and in overtime.

This game also arrived during a notable week for Michigan State athletics. Two nights earlier, the basketball team beat Duke in the Champions Classic, a game previewed in our Michigan State vs Duke preview. Tom Izzo discussed that test at length in his November 9 press conference. The hockey team could not match that result on Thursday, but it did earn a point on the road against a rival playing its best hockey of the season.

What the Loss Means for Michigan State

First, the direct cost is small. Michigan State still earned a point in its Big Ten opener. The Spartans remain 6-3-0, and their season goals are unchanged. They are chasing a fourth straight Big Ten regular-season title. One overtime loss on the road does not change that picture.

Second, the pattern is worth watching. This was the third straight two-game series in which Michigan State lost the opening game. The Spartans also dropped the series opener against Boston University last weekend before answering with a 5-0 shutout. Slow starts to a series are becoming a habit. Head coach Adam Nightingale will want that corrected quickly.

Finally, the response comes fast. Michigan State and Notre Dame finish the series on Friday night, November 13, at Compton Family Ice Arena. Puck drop is set for 7 p.m. ET, and the game streams on Peacock. After that, the Spartans face Michigan in a home-and-home series on November 20 and 21. A win on Friday would split the weekend, steady the Big Ten start, and end the series-opening slide.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*