Northwestern vs Ohio State Review: Buckeyes Grind Out 28-19 Win to Snap Losing Streak

Ohio State 28, Northwestern 19 final score graphic from Michigan Sports Entertainment

Northwestern vs Ohio State Review: Buckeyes Grind Out 28-19 Win to Snap Losing Streak

Ohio State needed a win more than it needed style points on Saturday, and it got one the hard way. The Buckeyes built a lead, let Northwestern pull within a point in the third quarter, and then leaned on their defense, their ground game and Jeremiah Smith to close out a 28-19 victory at Ohio Stadium.

The win snapped a two-game losing streak for No. 20 Ohio State, which improved to 7-3 overall and 5-2 in the Big Ten. Northwestern fell to 6-4 overall and 3-4 in conference play. For a Michigan audience, the result matters for a simple reason: Ohio State is still alive, still flawed, and still two weeks away from hosting Michigan with something left to play for.

Freshman quarterback Luke Fahey earned the first win of his starting career. He completed 21 of 32 passes for 201 yards and three touchdowns, with one interception. Smith caught 11 of those passes for 117 yards and a touchdown, and in the process became the Big Ten’s career receiving yards leader.

Northwestern Took the First Punch, Then Ohio State Settled In

The afternoon did not start cleanly for the home team. Fahey threw an interception on Ohio State’s opening drive, and Northwestern turned the early chance into points. The Buckeyes’ defense limited the damage, though. Senior defensive tackle Will Smith Jr. recorded a third-down sack, and the Wildcats settled for a 44-yard field goal by Jackson Kleather and a 3-0 lead.

Ohio State answered with the drive that changed the record book. Smith broke the Big Ten career receiving yards record on a 22-yard catch near the end of the first quarter, passing Purdue’s John Standeford. The Buckeyes finished the quarter with a 94-57 advantage in total offense, even though they had not yet scored.

The points came quickly in the second quarter. Fahey found sophomore running back Isaiah West for a four-yard touchdown pass early in the period, putting Ohio State ahead 7-3. It was West’s first career receiving touchdown, and it was his third connection with Fahey on that drive alone.

Northwestern replied with a second Kleather field goal to cut the margin to 7-6. Ohio State then produced its longest sustained drive of the half. Bo Jackson capped a 14-play, 82-yard march with a two-yard touchdown run out of the Wildcat formation with 2:51 left before halftime, giving the Buckeyes a 14-6 lead they carried into the break.

A One-Point Game in the Third Quarter

Northwestern made its best move right after halftime. Quarterback Nicco Marchiol led an eight-play, 58-yard drive on the Wildcats’ opening possession of the second half, and he finished it himself with a two-yard rushing touchdown. Suddenly Ohio State’s lead was down to 14-13, and a restless home crowd had reason to worry.

Ohio State also wasted a chance to stretch the lead. Fahey delivered a deep ball to Chris Henry Jr. that likely would have gone for a long touchdown, but Henry dropped it. That miss could have become the turning point of the game. Instead, the Buckeyes answered Northwestern’s touchdown with their own long drive.

Fahey capped a 13-play, 83-yard drive by finding senior wide receiver Devin McCuin for an eight-yard touchdown with 2:52 left in the third quarter. The play came on fourth-and-1, a call that showed real trust in the freshman quarterback. Rather than settle for a field goal and a four-point lead, Ohio State went for the touchdown and got it, moving ahead 21-13.

Special teams then swung the game for good in the fourth quarter. Northwestern’s Drew Wagner muffed a punt by Joe McGuire, and long snapper Dalton Riggs recovered at the Northwestern 10-yard line with 7:25 left. Three plays later, Fahey threw a 10-yard touchdown pass to Smith, and the lead was 28-13 with 6:33 to play.

Northwestern was not finished. A fumble recovery by Braden Turner gave the Wildcats one last possession, and Marchiol hit tight end Luke Dehnicke for a 17-yard touchdown as time expired. That made the final score 28-19, closer on paper than the final minutes felt once Smith had scored.

Shop Detroit Lions, Tigers, Pistons and Red Wings gear at The MSE Shop

Smith’s Record Day Carried the Offense

Smith’s numbers need context, because Saturday was not just another productive game for the junior wideout. His 11 catches for 117 yards brought his career receiving total to 3,875 yards, the most in Big Ten history. He passed Standeford’s 3,788 yards, and he is now 125 yards short of 4,000 for his career.

The touchdown was the 42nd receiving score of Smith’s career, extending his own conference record. He also climbed to sixth on the Big Ten’s career receptions list with 243 catches. Ohio State’s official recap noted that Smith is the only receiver in program history with more than 3,000 career receiving yards, and that he has three 1,000-yard receiving seasons.

Fahey targeted Smith 17 times, so the plan was no secret. Northwestern knew where the ball was going and still could not stop it. When Ohio State needed a first down, it looked for Smith. When it needed the clinching touchdown, it looked for Smith again, and he delivered from 10 yards out.

The ground game gave Fahey the support a young quarterback needs. Jackson carried 20 times for 114 yards and a touchdown, according to the game statistics reported by Eleven Warriors and the Columbus Dispatch. As a team, Ohio State rushed for 168 yards, a sharp improvement after being held to 53 rushing yards in the loss to Oregon a week earlier. In total, the Buckeyes gained 369 yards, with 201 through the air and 168 on the ground.

The Pass Rush Finally Broke Through

The defensive story was just as important. Ohio State recorded five sacks, its highest total in a game this season. Fifth-year defensive end Kenyatta Jackson Jr. led the way with six tackles, including two tackles for loss and two sacks. Senior defensive end Qua Russaw added five tackles, including three tackles for loss and a sack.

That pressure mattered against a familiar opponent. Northwestern’s offense is run by former Ohio State offensive coordinator Chip Kelly, who won a national championship with the Buckeyes in 2024 before moving to the opposite sideline. Ohio State held Kelly’s offense to 278 total yards and, most importantly, just 53 rushing yards on 29 carries.

Marchiol still had a solid day through the air. He completed 18 of 31 passes for 225 yards, scored on the ground, and threw the late touchdown to Dehnicke. Dehnicke caught five passes for 88 yards and a score, while running back Caleb Komolafe led Northwestern with 54 rushing yards on 11 carries. The Wildcats also recorded three takeaways, including Turner’s interception and fumble recovery, which is why the game stayed uncomfortable for so long.

In the end, though, Ohio State won the line of scrimmage. The Buckeyes held the ball for 32:51, gained 24 first downs to Northwestern’s 15, and converted their only fourth-down attempt. Northwestern has now lost 12 straight games in this series and has not won at Ohio Stadium since 1971.

What It Means for Michigan and the Big Ten Race

For Michigan fans, the takeaway is not that Ohio State has fixed everything. It has not. The Buckeyes turned the ball over, dropped a likely touchdown, and needed a muffed punt to finally put away a 6-4 Northwestern team at home. A team that lost to USC and Oregon in consecutive weeks still has clear problems, starting with a freshman quarterback who is learning on the job after taking over for the injured Julian Sayin.

The takeaway is that Ohio State did not quit on its season. Head coach Ryan Day said after the game that the last two weeks had not been fun, and that life is about how a team handles adversity. His players responded with effort, if not a clean performance, and kept their outside hopes for the College Football Playoff and the Big Ten Championship Game alive for another week. As MSE has tracked in its College Football Playoff rankings coverage, a three-loss team needs help from across the country, and Ohio State is no exception.

The road now gets harder, not easier. Ohio State closes its road schedule at Nebraska on Saturday, November 21, its first trip to Lincoln since 2021. Northwestern also plays on the road that day, at Minnesota. After Nebraska, Ohio State finishes the regular season against Michigan, in the game that will define how both teams remember November.

That is why Saturday mattered beyond Columbus. Had Ohio State lost a third straight game, it would have arrived at the Michigan game playing only for pride. Instead, the Buckeyes arrive at the final two weeks at 7-3, with a record-setting receiver, an improving freshman quarterback, and a pass rush that finally showed up. Michigan will still like its chances. It just cannot assume Ohio State will fold.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*