The diagnosis the Lions expected became official this week. Aidan Hutchinson tore the ACL in his right knee on the opening drive of Sunday’s 35-10 win over New England in Munich. He landed awkwardly after celebrating his sixth sack of the season. Follow-up testing on Monday confirmed the tear. It also brought the one piece of good news available: no other significant damage in the knee. His season is over. His focus now moves to 2027.
What he leaves behind is a 7-2 team on a five-game winning streak. Its first-place standing offers no protection at all. Minnesota and Chicago are also 7-2. Detroit sits atop the NFC North only because of its 2-0 division record, the first tiebreaker in a three-way tie. Dan Campbell said Tuesday that no single player can replace what Hutchinson does. He is right, and he knows it. The question for the final eight games is whether the defense as a whole can.
What the Lions Lose
Start with the production. In nine games, Hutchinson recorded six sacks, 24 tackles and one forced fumble. The sack total undersells him. His 52 quarterback pressures were the most on the team by a wide margin. Alim McNeill is next with 35. They accounted for more than a quarter of Detroit’s 195 pressures as a team. Six of the Lions’ 32 sacks came from Hutchinson, and those 32 sacks rank third in the NFL.
The bigger loss is structural. Hutchinson is the one rusher on this roster that an offense has to plan for. Protection slides his way. Tight ends and backs stay in to chip him. The quarterback’s internal clock runs faster because of him. That attention is what turned McNeill, D.J. Wonnum and rookie Derrick Moore loose on single blocks all season. It does not show up in any box score. Detroit’s defense has allowed 22.1 points per game, 15th in the league. Lately, though, it has been playing its best football. The Lions have allowed 15.5 points per game across the five-game winning streak, according to the Detroit Free Press.
There was a first piece of evidence on Sunday. Hutchinson left in the first quarter. The Lions still sacked New England’s quarterbacks four more times and held the Patriots to 151 total yards. It came against a backup quarterback in a game that was decided by halftime, so it proves only so much. But it is the template Detroit has to live on now: pressure by committee, or not at all.
Who Has to Step Up
Campbell addressed the depth question directly at his Tuesday press conference, and he did not hedge. “One guy cannot pick up the slack of Aidan Hutchinson, but we have enough here to weather this storm and rise above it,” Campbell said. “We are much better equipped than we were then. That’s the reason why we have the depth that we have in that room.”
The first name on the list is Wonnum. The 29-year-old veteran has started opposite Hutchinson all season after signing a one-year deal in March. He spent four years in Minnesota and two in Carolina, where he built a résumé of 30 career sacks. He has six sacks this season, matching Hutchinson’s total, and he sets a firm edge against the run. Wonnum missed the Miami game with a concussion, returned Sunday in Munich and recorded a sack. Detroit needs him healthy and on the field for starter’s snaps the rest of the way.
Moore’s Emergence
The second name is the one with the highest ceiling. Moore, a second-round pick out of Michigan in April, barely played early. He had 52 snaps and no tackles through Week 4. When Wonnum sat out at Miami on November 8, Moore played a season-high 33 snaps. He produced the first two sacks of his career. It was the first two-sack game by a Lions rookie since Hutchinson himself in January 2023. He added two more sacks against New England. Four sacks in two games is a small sample. But it is the exact profile Detroit drafted: a rotational rusher who now has to become a fixture.
The Interior Rotation
Behind them, the interior has to keep producing. McNeill’s 6.5 sacks now lead the team. Campbell name-checked the whole room on Tuesday. McNeill, Skyler Gill-Howard and Tyleik Williams were included. The message for each was the same: we need more. Tyler Lacy and Eric O’Neill round out the edge depth. The Lions claimed Tyrus Wheat off waivers from Dallas on Monday. Wheat played 15 games for Detroit last season, mostly on special teams. Campbell said the appeal is simple: “We were fired up to get Wheat back, because he does know our system.”
There is no outside rescue coming. The trade deadline passed on November 10 and the Lions stood pat. Whatever this pass rush is in December, it is already in the building.
They Have Survived This Before
Detroit has played this season before, in a sense. In 2024, Hutchinson fractured the tibia and fibula in his left leg at Dallas in Week 6. He missed the final 12 games — and still led that team with 7.5 sacks. The Lions went 11-1 without him and finished 15-2 with the NFC’s No. 1 seed. Their defense finished seventh in the league in points allowed.
The cautionary part came in January. In the divisional round at Ford Field, Washington won 45-31, and Detroit did not sack rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels once. A defense can scheme its way through a regular season without its best rusher. Against a top quarterback in the playoffs, the shortage tends to get exposed. That history is the honest frame for the next two months. The regular season is survivable, and January is where the bill comes due.
The Joseph Factor
The defense’s weakest number this season is not sacks. It is takeaways. Detroit has forced nine turnovers in nine games, near the bottom of the league. The defense has otherwise been built on pressure. That is where the week’s other news matters.
Campbell said Tuesday that the plan is to activate safety Kerby Joseph this week. The plan is to play him Sunday against Tampa Bay. Campbell described the pitch count as looser than the one Brian Branch had in his first game back. The formal activation had not been announced as of Tuesday, so it remains a plan rather than a completed transaction. But Joseph has not played since October 12, 2025, because of a knee cartilage condition. His return changes the math in the secondary. Joseph led the NFL with nine interceptions in 2024 and earned first-team All-Pro honors. He has 20 interceptions in 55 career games. Even in his shortened 2025 season, he intercepted three passes in six games.
The fit is direct. Without Hutchinson, quarterbacks will hold the ball a beat longer against a four-man rush that no longer features a must-double edge rusher. Or they will get it out quickly and test the coverage. A center fielder with Joseph’s range lets defensive coordinator Kelvin Sheppard hold his coverage together longer. He can disguise more, and trust that a hurried throw has a chance of being taken away. Joseph does not walk into an empty room, either. Chuck Clark has started every game at safety. Branch is back from his Achilles recovery. Andre Cisco, acquired from the Jets for a 2028 sixth-round pick, adds depth. The takeaway threat is what has been missing.
The Scheme Question
Sheppard’s defense has been built on the front four. Detroit’s 32 sacks rank third in the NFL without living on the blitz. The stunt game up front has been a staple all season. That identity gets harder to sustain when the best individual rusher in the group is gone. Offenses can play the remaining ends straight up.
Expect more manufacturing. The levers are obvious ones: more stunts and games up front, and Derrick Barnes sent as an added rusher. The occasional safety blitz is another, along with simulated pressure that shows blitz and bails into coverage. Campbell praised Sheppard and his staff on Tuesday. They have used the whole roster and gotten the defense to play as one unit. That, more than any single replacement, is the bet Detroit is making.
The Road Ahead
The schedule does not offer much room to experiment. Tampa Bay visits Ford Field on Sunday at 1 p.m. ET. The Buccaneers’ own uncertainty helps. Baker Mayfield’s status is in genuine doubt after a foot injury. Reporting describes him as no better than 50-50 to play. Chicago follows on Thanksgiving, four days later. December brings a trip to Atlanta on December 6 and Tennessee at home on December 13. Then comes a Sunday night game at Minnesota on December 20. The Lions host the New York Giants on December 28. The closing run goes through the division — at Chicago on January 3 and at Green Bay in Week 18.
Four of the final eight games are against the NFC North. Three of the last four are on the road. In a three-way tie at the top of the division, every one of those games is effectively a two-game swing.
The Bottom Line
The Lions do not need to find a new Hutchinson. There isn’t one. They need Wonnum’s steadiness, Moore’s emergence, McNeill’s interior push, Joseph’s takeaways and Sheppard’s scheming. Those pieces have to add up to something close to what one player provided. The 2024 season says that is enough to win a division and a top seed. It also says what happens in January if the pass rush does not travel. Detroit has eight games to build the collective version of its best defender. Sunday against Tampa Bay is the first look at whether it works.


Leave a Reply