Lions Position Grades: Defense Earns Top Marks in Miami Win

Detroit Lions Grades

These Lions position grades cover one game only. Detroit beat the Miami Dolphins 19-9 on Sunday, November 8, at Hard Rock Stadium. Each grade below rests on verified numbers from that game. Season context is added only where it helps explain the grade.

The overall picture is clear. Detroit’s defense and kicking game carried the afternoon. Meanwhile, the passing offense and offensive line struggled against a 1-7 opponent. Both truths matter before the Munich trip.

Quarterback: C

Jared Goff completed 17 of 25 passes for 170 yards. He threw no touchdowns and one interception. It was his first game this season without a touchdown pass. It was also only his second interception of the year. Miami sacked him three times in the first half.

Goff improved after halftime, however. He hit Jameson Williams for 31 yards and Amon-Ra St. Brown for 17 yards on the touchdown drive. He also converted a late fourth-and-1 sneak. Still, a 170-yard day against a rebuilding defense is below his standard. The grade reflects a managed second half, not a controlled game.

Running Backs: B-

Jahmyr Gibbs carried 20 times for 74 yards and scored the game’s only touchdown. That score came on fourth-and-1 from the Miami 8. It gave Detroit a 16-6 lead late in the third quarter. Gibbs also helped close the game on the final drive.

The limits were real, though. Gibbs averaged 3.7 yards per carry. Miami also dropped him for a loss three times in a four-play span in the second quarter. In addition, he had no receptions after entering as one of the league’s most productive receiving backs. Poor blocking explains part of that. The touchdown and the finish lift the grade.

Shop Detroit Lions gear at The MSE Shop

Offensive Line: D+

This was the weakest unit on the field for Detroit. Goff was sacked three times and pressured throughout the first half. Josh Uche hit Goff’s arm on the interception. Miles Frazier made his first career start at left guard. He allowed a pressure that led to a sack and another that contributed to the interception. He was also flagged for holding.

Detroit rushed for only 102 yards as a team. Christian Mahogany was benched for team rules, according to Dan Campbell. Center Cade Mays also remained out with an ankle injury. The line settled slightly after halftime. Even so, this performance will not be enough against New England. It is the clearest concern from the win.

Receivers and Tight Ends: B-

Amon-Ra St. Brown caught eight passes for 86 yards on 10 targets. He played through a rib injury. His consistency gave Goff one reliable option all afternoon. Jameson Williams added the game’s longest offensive play, a 31-yard catch that started the touchdown drive.

Sam LaPorta caught four passes for 32 yards on five targets. Beyond those three, production was thin. No other Lion finished with more than 25 receiving yards. The group also had to work through poor protection and a heavy Miami pass rush. Within those limits, the top three delivered when Detroit finally needed explosive plays.

Defensive Line: A

This was the best unit on the field. Detroit held Miami to 228 net yards and 74 rushing yards. It sacked Malik Willis three times and hit him seven times. Rookie Derrick Moore recorded two sacks in his first career start. Alim McNeill added the third sack. That production came even though Miami committed five holding penalties.

Aidan Hutchinson did not record a sack. Even so, he shaped the game. He drew holding calls that erased two of Miami’s biggest plays. The group also limited Miami to 3.4 yards per carry. That is the standard for this line, and it held again on Sunday.

Linebackers: B+

Malcolm Rodriguez started in place of Jack Campbell. He led the team with eight tackles and a pass breakup. He also filled his run fits without a clear mistake. Derrick Barnes handled the defensive communication duties and steadied the group. Our Lions at Dolphins preview flagged this group as the biggest risk of the week. Its performance eased that worry.

The grade stays below an A for one reason. Campbell remains the heart of this group, and his absence showed in small moments. Miami found some space in the middle of the field. Still, the unit kept its shape. It also finished as the emotional leader of the defense.

Shop Detroit Lions, Tigers, Pistons and Red Wings gear at The MSE Shop

Secondary: A-

Chuck Clark set the tone with his third-quarter interception. He returned it to the Miami 26 and set up the field goal that made it 9-3. Brian Branch added six tackles and a pass breakup. The unit also held Miami to 128 net passing yards.

The secondary played without two starters. Kerby Joseph and D.J. Reed were both out. Even so, Miami never found a consistent deep threat. The group’s only real blemish was the coverage that allowed a 46-yard fake punt completion. That play counts against the grade, but not by much.

Special Teams: A

Jake Bates was perfect again. He made all four field goals from 28, 40, 33, and 43 yards. His 43-yard kick with 4:28 left restored a two-score lead. Zane Gonzalez, by contrast, missed a 38-yard attempt at the end of the first half. That swing alone was worth six points.

Jack Fox added a highlight of his own. He completed an 11-yard pass on a fake punt in the second quarter. That play extended a drive. It also showed the trust Dan Campbell has in this group. Miami completed a fake punt of its own, so the grade is not perfect. Still, this was a clear win for Detroit’s specialists.

Coaching Staff: B+

Dan Campbell went 3-for-3 on fourth down. Those calls produced the game’s only touchdown. They also produced a key fake punt conversion. He also managed the game well after halftime. Detroit scored 10 points in the third quarter and never trailed again.

The deductions are real, though. The offense started slowly for the third straight week. Nine penalties also hurt the rhythm. Christian Mahogany’s benching for team rules remains an open question. Campbell handled that issue with his usual directness. He also kept the team focused on Jack Campbell after a difficult week.

Overall Team Grade: B

The overall team grade is a B. Detroit won by 10 points on the road. It also held its opponent without a touchdown. Those facts matter more than the style points. The Lions are now 6-2 with a defense playing at its best level of the season.

The biggest concern is the offensive line and the passing game. That pair must improve before the Munich game against New England. The defense and special teams, however, give Detroit a margin that travels. See the MSE Pro Football Weekly Week 9 preview and Inside the Coach’s Office.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*