The Playoff Picture Just Got Turned Upside Down After Saturday’s CFP Shakeup

The first College Football Playoff rankings of the season were exactly four days old when Saturday arrived and rearranged them. The committee released its first Top 25 on Tuesday, November 3, with Miami at No. 1, Georgia at No. 2, Utah at No. 3, Indiana at No. 4 and Alabama at No. 5. By midnight on Saturday, the No. 1 team had lost, the No. 2 team had made the strongest statement of the season, two unbeaten teams had tightened their grip, and the bottom half of the projected bracket had been shuffled almost beyond recognition. Tuesday night’s second rankings release, at 9 p.m. ET on ESPN, will not look much like the first one.

The night the top spot changed hands

The headline result came in South Bend, where Notre Dame beat Miami 31-24. The Fighting Irish, No. 11 in the committee’s first rankings, built a 24-3 lead in the third quarter behind quarterback CJ Carr, who completed 29 of 40 passes for 319 yards and three touchdowns, two of them to Micah Gilbert. Miami rallied behind Darian Mensah, who threw for 276 yards and three scores, but the Hurricanes were playing without star receiver Malachi Toney, sidelined with an ankle injury, and the comeback ran out of time. Miami is 8-1 and hardly finished as a playoff team, but the Hurricanes no longer control the top seed, and the road win they needed to validate the committee’s faith in them became someone else’s signature victory instead.

While Miami was falling, Georgia was removing all doubt about who replaces the Hurricanes at No. 1. The Bulldogs went into Oxford and beat Ole Miss 42-7, outgaining the Rebels 481-252 and ending Ole Miss’s 16-game home winning streak. Gunner Stockton threw four touchdown passes and ran for another score, and Talyn Taylor caught four passes for 140 yards and three touchdowns. Georgia, now 8-1, did not just win the weekend’s most lopsided ranked matchup. The Bulldogs avenged last season’s Sugar Bowl loss to Ole Miss and gave the committee a simple decision at the top of Tuesday’s ballot.

Shop Detroit Lions, Tigers, Pistons and Red Wings gear at The MSE Shop

Who helped themselves

Notre Dame is the obvious answer. The Irish were the team the committee pointedly asked to prove something, sitting at No. 11 with a resume short on ranked wins. Beating the No. 1 team in the country answers that question in one night. At 8-1, Notre Dame should make the biggest jump of any contender on Tuesday, into the top six and possibly higher, with a clear path to hosting a first-round game if the Irish win out.

Utah and UCLA, the two unbeaten teams the committee had ranked third and eighth, both did exactly what unbeaten teams are supposed to do in November. Utah beat rival BYU 28-20 in the Holy War to reach 9-0, and UCLA won 34-20 at Minnesota to get to 9-0 as well. Neither win was spectacular, and that is the point. With Miami’s loss clearing space above them, the Utes and Bruins should both move up on Tuesday, and Utah has a legitimate case for No. 2.

Behind them, Alabama handled LSU 31-13 to improve to 7-2 and strengthen its hold on a top-five spot. Tennessee routed Kentucky 34-6, a result that lifts the Volunteers and badly damages the Wildcats in the same stroke. Texas beat Missouri 34-20 to keep its push alive. And Oregon, ranked all the way down at No. 23 by the committee last week, went into Columbus and beat Ohio State 41-28. No team ranked that low has any business being an afterthought after a win like that, and the Ducks should be the week’s other major climber, from the edge of the rankings into the heart of the bracket conversation.

Indiana, fourth in the first rankings, helped itself by doing nothing at all. The Hoosiers were idle while the teams around them traded losses, and an 8-1 team that watches Miami and Kentucky lose on the same Saturday gains ground without taking a snap. Farther down the ballot, the quiet winners kept their seasons intact: Houston beat Cincinnati 31-24, Iowa won 24-10 at Northwestern, and Wake Forest overwhelmed Merrimack 77-0. None of those results changes the top of the bracket, but each keeps a two-loss-or-better resume in the committee’s pile for the final three weeks, which is where at-large arguments are won.

Who hurt themselves

Ole Miss is the clearest casualty. A 42-7 home loss is the kind of result the committee remembers, and at 6-3 the Rebels have gone from the top ten to the outside of the projected field in one evening. Kentucky’s 34-6 loss at Tennessee carries the same problem: the Wildcats were No. 6 in the first rankings, and a three-score loss to a conference rival will cost them several spots and most of their margin for error. LSU, beaten soundly at home by Alabama, and Florida, which lost 23-7 to Oklahoma, both slid further from the cut line.

Ohio State’s situation is more delicate. The Buckeyes, No. 12 in the first rankings and sitting exactly on the bracket’s edge, lost at home to Oregon. That is the kind of loss that drops a team below the line entirely, and it leaves Ohio State needing help over the final three weeks. BYU’s loss at Utah was more forgivable — a one-score game on the road against an unbeaten rival — but at 7-2 the Cougars no longer have room for another stumble. Missouri’s loss at Texas rounds out a Saturday that was unkind to just about everyone who started the day ranked between sixth and eighteenth.

Shop Detroit Lions, Tigers, Pistons and Red Wings gear at The MSE Shop

The Group of Five bid and the bubble

The quietest important race in the sport still runs through Boise. Boise State, the only Group of Five team in the committee’s first Top 25 at No. 25, buried Colorado State 64-38 to reach 8-1. Under the current format, the five highest-ranked conference champions make the field, and Boise remains the only non-power-conference team the committee has ranked at all. The Broncos should climb into the low twenties on Tuesday, and their grip on that bid is stronger than it was a week ago. The bubble behind them is a crowd of two-loss power-conference teams — Ohio State, BYU, Texas Tech among them — fighting for the last at-large spots. Texas Tech did itself no favors and no real harm by surviving West Virginia 53-48 in a Lubbock shootout. The Red Raiders trailed 48-41 in the fourth quarter before Thomas Castellanos, who threw for 362 yards and five touchdowns and ran for 102 more, led the comeback, sealed by a safety with 1:24 to play. Tech is 8-1 and stays in the Big 12 race, but a defense that gave up 582 yards will give the committee pause.

There was a local footnote to the chaos. Michigan State’s 15-6 win at Michigan on Saturday night does not move the national picture, but it knocked the Wolverines to 5-4 and gave the Spartans the Paul Bunyan Trophy, and it is the kind of result that reshapes how both programs’ Novembers feel even with the playoff out of reach for each.

What Tuesday should show

Expect Georgia at No. 1, with unbeaten Utah and UCLA next in some order. Alabama and Indiana, which was idle this week, should fill out the top five, with Notre Dame’s surge landing the Irish right behind them. Miami should settle in the back half of the top ten rather than falling out of the field — a seven-point road loss to a top-ten team is damaging, not disqualifying. Tennessee, Texas and Oregon should all climb, and Oregon’s rise will be the tell for how much the committee values one great win over a season of steady ones.

A reasonable projection for Tuesday’s top twelve, then, looks something like this: Georgia, Utah, UCLA, Alabama, Indiana, Notre Dame, Miami, Tennessee, Texas, Oregon, BYU and Texas Tech, with Boise State positioned as the Group of Five’s champion-in-waiting just outside that group and ready to take a spot the moment one of the two-loss teams in front of it slips. Ohio State would be the notable name missing from that list, which tells you everything about what Saturday did to the Buckeyes. The bottom of the projected bracket is where Tuesday gets interesting: Ohio State, Ole Miss and Kentucky are all sliding toward the line at once, and only some of them are still going to be on the right side of it. Four days after the first rankings, the playoff picture is upside down. Tuesday night, the committee has to turn it right side up again.

5 Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. Ryan Day Press Conference November 10: Fahey Starts, Staff on Notice
  2. Marcus Freeman Press Conference November 7: Notre Dame Tops No. 1 Miami
  3. Ryan Day Press Conference November 11: Consequences for Losing
  4. Ryan Day Press Conference November 14: Character in Victory
  5. Walsh vs Northwood Review: Timberwolves Win 17-14

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*